On his fourth birthday, my son upset me.
We're at that stage of teaching him to be grateful for what he has and what he receives. We are also, at precisely the same time, trying to get him interested in something, anything, other than monster trucks. Those two efforts met each other on his birthday... they didn't get along.
When friends and family asked what to get him, we said, "anything other than monster trucks".
(I already know what you're thinking.)
Knowing they are his unequivocal favourite, and knowing exactly what we were doing. It had been bubbling under the surface for weeks, and a birthday is a very public place for that sort of thing to surface.
He opened gift after gift that we wanted for him and that he did not want for himself.
You can picture the face.
Defiance.
I was upset with him. I want to be honest about that, because looking back, his innocent reaction was completely warranted. Free of any social constraints, the right of a toddler is to be unfiltered.
If someone gives me something I don't want, convention tells me to say thank you, smile, appreciate it, and then quietly never use it again. That is simply the polite, drawn-out version of the same verdict. Roman skipped the admin. One glance, one ruling: no monster truck, no value. Some could even call that... efficient. And considerably more honest than we (adults) typically are.
When your child only wants one thing
The mistake wasn't the gift; it was the brief.
And I was the person who issued it.
For the lesson in this story, I will openly admit what I got wrong here and hope that it helps some of you.
We tried to broaden him by subtraction. We looked at the thing he loved most and treated it as the obstacle, as though his world would grow the moment we took the trucks out of it. It doesn't work that way. Removing the thing a child loves doesn't make room for something new. It just removes the thing they love.
A birthday is not a curriculum. If you want to widen a child's world, you don't go around the thing they're obsessed with. You go through it.
Six months later, a blackboard
Here's how I know.
Over the next six months, the interests we'd been trying to force on him arrived anyway. They just arrived through the monster trucks instead of in place of them.
His grandparents had given him a blackboard, to help with his writing. Another one of our gifts, if I'm honest. Something we wanted for him. For a while, it sat there.
Then we started using it to keep score for his Monster Truck Freestyle Competition.
He now uses that blackboard almost every day. His ideas board, his writing board, entirely his own. Same board, same child. We just stopped asking him to come to us and went to him instead.
Mission accomplished.
What this has to do with books
That blackboard is, more or less, the entire idea behind what we built.
A story is the easiest blackboard there is. If your child is inside it, and the thing they love is in there with them, you can take them almost anywhere. The first day at school. The dentist. A new baby arriving. Not by talking them out of monster trucks, but by putting the monster trucks in the story and driving them there.
How to choose a gift for a child who only wants one thing: don't try to replace the obsession, use it. Children reject gifts chosen to broaden them because the gift serves the giver's goal rather than the child's interest. The more reliable approach is to route the new skill or experience through the thing they already love, so the obsession becomes the doorway rather than the obstacle.
So yes, this has been a very long-winded way of telling you to buy a book, and sure, I'll own that.
But buy the one they'll actually read.
Because the honest test of a gift isn't the face someone pulls when they open it. It's what they're still reaching for six months later.
Ready to create your child's first story?
Available now on iOS, download the app and create your first story.